Brainwash yourself, in a good way

You have been brainwashed once already. As a child you heard the same few lines again and again, from people you couldn't argue with, until they became the voice in your head. Propaganda and advertising use the same method on purpose. HermeticMind hands it to you, for beliefs you choose.

Where the voice in your head comes from

We learn to talk to ourselves by taking in how adults talked to us. The psychologist Lev Vygotsky described inner speech as other people's speech turned inward: the warnings, orders and judgements a child hears become the words they later use on themselves. So a parent's "You're useless" can become, years later, "I'm useless".

It is common. In the Adverse Childhood Experiences study, published in 1998, more than 8,000 adults in California answered questions about their childhood. About one in nine said a parent or other adult at home often swore at them, insulted them or put them down. Adults who were put down like this as children tend to be harder on themselves, and the old words keep running as self-criticism (Sachs-Ericsson and colleagues, 2006).

It doesn't take cruelty. Ordinary family sayings plant beliefs too. Researchers call the ones about money "money scripts": they form in childhood as children try to make sense of money in their family, are often handed down through generations and usually sit below awareness (Klontz and colleagues, 2011). Two lines from their questionnaire: "Rich people are greedy." "It is not okay to have more than you need."

Why it feels true

  • It speaks as fact. "I'm useless." "I always fail." First person, present tense, never "I might be".
  • It came from authority, at an age before you could question it.
  • It has been repeated more times than you could count. Repetition makes a statement feel true. Psychologists first showed it in 1977 (Hasher, Goldstein and Toppino), and later found it works even when a statement goes against what people already know (Fazio and colleagues, 2015).
  • It is loaded with feeling. Carl Jung called a knot of charged memories and feelings like this a complex. His point was that we don't simply have complexes; they can have us.

A belief like that steers what you do. Albert Bandura argued that what you believe about your own ability shapes whether you start, how hard you try and how long you keep going (1977). The sociologist Robert Merton named the result the self-fulfilling prophecy (1948): a belief, acted on, brings about what it predicted. "I'm useless" stops you starting, the failure follows, and the voice says "See?"

Propaganda: the same method, used on purpose

Edward Bernays, Sigmund Freud's nephew, is often called the father of public relations. His 1928 book Propaganda opens: "The conscious and intelligent manipulation of the organized habits and opinions of the masses is an important element in democratic society."

He sold feelings, not facts. By his own account, in 1929 he had young women light cigarettes in New York's Easter parade as "torches of freedom", tying smoking to the wish for freedom. He borrowed authority too: for a client selling bacon, he had a doctor ask 5,000 physicians whether a hearty breakfast was better for people, and newspapers reported that about 4,500 agreed. Both stories come largely from Bernays's own retellings, but the method is plain: touch a feeling, borrow an authority, repeat.

Advertising: feeling, pictures and repetition

  • Feeling beats facts. Les Binet and Peter Field studied 996 advertising campaigns and found emotional ones were about twice as likely as rational ones to produce very large profit gains.
  • It speaks as if it's already true. L'Oréal's "Because I'm worth it" was written in 1971 by a 23-year-old copywriter, Ilon Specht, and it is still running. It doesn't argue that you might be worth it.
  • Seeing it again makes you like it. The more often people see something, the more they tend to like it (Zajonc, 1968), even when they can't remember having seen it (Kunst-Wilson and Zajonc, 1980).
  • Pictures pass their feeling on. Pair something with what people already like, and the liking spreads to it: a reliable effect across 214 studies (Hofmann and colleagues, 2010). In a classic study, hearing music people liked while seeing a product changed which product they chose (Gorn, 1982).
  • Pictures stick. After a test with 10,000 pictures, Lionel Standing wrote that "the capacity of recognition memory for pictures is almost limitless, when measured under appropriate conditions" (1973). Pictures are remembered better than words.

So brainwash yourself back

HermeticMind puts the same tools in your hands, on lines you choose:

  • The slogan: your affirmation, in the old voice's own grammar: "I", present tense, settled fact.
  • The feeling: words you can feel, in a warm voice on your side.
  • The pictures: in the desktop app, your own pictures, chosen because they already make the goal feel real. A picture can carry its own words.
  • The repetition: in the desktop app, each line fades in with its picture at random moments and places on your screen through the working day. In the mobile app, you hear them.
  • The variety: one belief said many ways, so it stays fresh. Seeing a line a second time gives the biggest jump in how true it feels, and the rise slows after that (Hassan and Barber, 2021).
  • No effort: you don't stop work to recite. Émile Coué, the pharmacist behind "Every day and in every way, I get better and better", taught that straining to believe works against you.

Start with how to write an affirmation, or download a free deck.

What the research does and doesn't say

Most studies of repetition used trivia statements, not beliefs about yourself, and we know of no study showing that repeated affirmations turn around a belief someone holds firmly the other way. Big claims can also backfire: people with low self-esteem who repeated "I am a lovable person" felt worse afterwards (Wood, Perunovic and Lee, 2009). That is why our decks keep each claim small. HermeticMind promises no results. It gives you a way to repeat the lines you choose, as often as the old ones were repeated to you. If the old voice comes from real harm, talk to a doctor or counsellor as well.

Sources: Vygotsky's account of inner speech. Felitti, Anda and colleagues (1998), American Journal of Preventive Medicine. Sachs-Ericsson and colleagues (2006), Journal of Affective Disorders. Klontz, Britt, Mentzer and Klontz (2011), Journal of Financial Therapy. Hasher, Goldstein and Toppino (1977). Fazio and colleagues (2015). Bandura (1977), Psychological Review. Merton (1948). Bernays, Propaganda (1928). Binet and Field, The Long and the Short of It (2013). Zajonc (1968); Kunst-Wilson and Zajonc (1980). Hofmann, De Houwer, Perugini, Baeyens and Crombez (2010), Psychological Bulletin. Gorn (1982), Journal of Marketing. Standing (1973), Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology. Hassan and Barber (2021). Wood, Perunovic and Lee (2009), Psychological Science. Coué, Self Mastery Through Conscious Autosuggestion.